Amazon.comā€™s Whole Foods Market doesnā€™t want to be forced to let workers wear ā€œBlack Lives Matterā€ masks and is pointing to the recent US Supreme Court ruling permitting a business owner to refuse services to same-sex couples to get federal regulators to back off.

National Labor Relations Board prosecutors have accused the grocer of stifling worker rights by banning staff from wearing BLM masks or pins on the job. The company countered in a filing that its own rights are being violated if itā€™s forced to allow BLM slogans to be worn with Whole Foods uniforms.

Amazon is the most prominent company to use the high courtā€™s June ruling that a Christian web designer was free to refuse to design sites for gay weddings, saying the case ā€œprovides a clear roadmapā€ to throw out the NLRBā€™s complaint.

The dispute is one of several in which labor board officials are considering what counts as legally-protected, work-related communication and activism on the job.

  • Saik0@lemmy.saik0.com
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    2
    Ā·
    1 year ago

    What if youā€™re a black teen and the only job you can get is at Whole Foods?

    Then donā€™t piss off the only employer in your area? Thatā€™s not Whole Foods [or anyone elses really] problem.

    Then your boss tells you not to acknowledge [BLM, please donā€™t conflate the scenario here]

    No. The policy is NO branding other than whole foods. This isnā€™t targeted at anyone in particular. If you believe that whole foods is treating you poorly then you leave the job. Thatā€™s it.

    Youā€™re so up youā€™re own ass, youā€™re unable to sympathize with any marginalized group

    Youā€™re so up your own that you didnā€™t even stop to realize that I might be part of those groups myself the funny part is my group was treated worse for literally hundreds of years longer but you do you. Youā€™re making assumptions without realizing that this has nothing to do with any of what your talking about. Itā€™s literally just a bog standard basic dress code, not an anti-BLM plot.

      • Saik0@lemmy.saik0.com
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        Ā·
        1 year ago

        Itā€™s literally not. If you insert any other argument then youā€™re wrong.

        https://www.reuters.com/legal/judge-dismisses-whole-foods-workers-lawsuit-over-black-lives-matter-masks-2023-01-23/

        ā€œThe evidence demonstrates only that Whole Foods did not strenuously enforce the dress code policy until mid-2020, and that when it increased enforcement, it did so uniformly,ā€ Burroughs wrote in a 28-page decision.

        You can literally read the full decision from the judge if you like. If you can find evidence that Whole Foods was acting against the employees unfairly, then Iā€™m sure the plaintiffs lawyers would like to hire you on as a partner in their firm.

      • Saik0@lemmy.saik0.com
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        3
        Ā·
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        Not even close. Iā€™m part of a marginalized group, but donā€™t make it my whole identity. I came from immigrant parents, am first generation American, worked hard to get where I am and am raising up those around me as well. You know what doesnā€™t help? Wearing a fucking pin or logo.

          • Saik0@lemmy.saik0.com
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            1
            Ā·
            1 year ago

            Letā€™s put this in perspective. What has Whole Foods done to warrant being protested against in regards to BLM? Is Whole Foods racist for applying a policy fairly across the board?

            Why would you protest Whole Foods if theyā€™ve done nothing wrong? Why would you stress your contract with a company youā€™re working for that has a known dress code in order to ā€œprotestā€ something that the company has no part in?

            What does the ā€œprotestā€ resolve at a Whole Foods? Does it make other people who are just trying to live uncomfortable to be confronted with something that is ultimately politically charged when they just want to buy some fucking frozen pizzaā€™s and milk for their family?

            Does protest

            Yes

            or symbolism

            No

            mean anything to you?

            If the Westboro Baptist Church or Scientologists set fire to all the neighboring black homes in their areaā€¦ and you went to Whole Foods to protest that actā€¦ Do you think that would be effective? Do you think it would be meaningful? Wouldnā€™t you rather see them protest where it matters? Like I dunnoā€¦ At the organization that actually created the problem or is actively participating in the problem?

            Since a job is effectively selling your time to work for a company in return for compensation itā€™s fair to the company to violate their policies while theyā€™re paying you?

            You talk about morals beforeā€¦ but cheating a company out of the contract that you signed seems pretty scummy. Like Iā€™ve said beforeā€¦ find another job if the morals of the company doesnā€™t align with your own.

              • Saik0@lemmy.saik0.com
                link
                fedilink
                English
                arrow-up
                1
                Ā·
                1 year ago

                Well I wouldnā€™t go to a different store to protest

                Rightā€¦ So what does THAT [or any reallyā€¦] particular Whole Foods have anything to do with BLM? So why protest while youā€™re working? Does it make sense to WORK for the people youā€™re apparently protesting against? Thatā€™s a bit counter-intuitiveā€¦


                And BLM is not POLITICAL

                https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Lives_Matter

                Black Lives Matter (BLM) is a decentralized political and social movement

                https://www.politico.com/news/2020/10/09/black-lives-matter-pac-428403

                Black Lives Matter launches a political action committee

                https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/21306771/black-lives-matter-george-floyd-protest-michael-kazin

                BLM is succeeding ā€” culturally and politically.

                Soā€¦ You sure about that? I can provide more if youā€™d likeā€¦


                Protesting isnā€™t done out of convenience, or postponed for the convenience of othersā€¦

                When youā€™ve sold your time to someone else, it shouldnā€™t be done at all. Or at the very least with their blessing/permission.


                And ā€œjust quitā€? What fucking cushy world do you live in where you can hop from job to job? Especially if you were black, or trans, and other places could be equally as discriminatory?

                The same ones you would if you lives near me. Thereā€™s plenty of jobs to have. Literally have access to dozens of jobs at several different wage points within walking distance of me. Theyā€™ve been publicly advertising the need for workers desperately for years at this point. But seeā€¦ you seem to be too entitled to just follow a simple fucking dress codeā€¦ so many places probably wont want to hire you since youā€™re unable to follow simple policies. If your job, whatever it isā€¦ decided that you need to show up in khakis and a button shirt starting tomorrow with no visible writing/logos (other than maybe the tags on the clothing itself)ā€¦ Is that racism? Would you scream that theyā€™re being unfair? Or maybe they just want you to appear more professional to your customers? But this is a different problem all together. Being desirable by companies usually means you play by their rules in regards to the time youā€™re working for them.

                  • Saik0@lemmy.saik0.com
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    arrow-up
                    1
                    Ā·
                    1 year ago

                    Iā€™ll let you have your long, elaborately structured final word , it doesnā€™t matter at this point really

                    If you say soā€¦ I actually would appreciate actual discussion on the matter. But a lot of what youā€™ve posted has instead been ad hominemā€¦ which is disappointing.

                    If rules mean that much to you, then thatā€™s fine, but some rules are made by people with ulterior motives.

                    I donā€™t give a shit about ā€œrulesā€. I just donā€™t understand why you work somewhereā€¦ agreeing to abide by their policiesā€¦ just to surprise pikachu when then actually enforce their policies? Then decide to try to sue the company for applying their policies fairly?

                    Further I donā€™t understand people like you going out of their way to claim itā€™s racismā€¦

                    Itā€™s like you said, a fucking pin.

                    That violates the contract/policies that you agree to in order to work thereā€¦ Like you said. Itā€™s just a pin. (even though before you were saying itā€™s much more than the pin/mask). I mean thatā€™s been my point all along. Itā€™s just a pin and ultimately means nothing on itā€™s own. Should they be allowed to wear a NAMBLA pin (not comparing the organizationsā€¦ Just proving a point)?

                    But if you honestly donā€™t believe that small acts of showing that there are good people out there,

                    I donā€™t think that a pin/design on a mask attests to ANYONEā€™s character. Nor if they even understand/agree with whatā€™s on the pin/mask. I have a shirt that I wear sometimes with ā€œNational Pro Fastpitchā€ā€¦ Iā€™ve never been part of the organization, nor do I even know what it is.

                    Yes, protest and strikes are what make real results.

                    Which wearing a pin is neither protest nor strikeā€¦ But do you agree that if people came to workā€¦ And held up signs all day about BLMā€¦ would the company then be fine to fire those people? What makes it any different then wearing that sign all day long? To your point earlierā€¦ Iā€™ll entertain for a moment that it could be a protest.

                    Protesting isnā€™t done out of convenience, or postponed for the convenience of othersā€¦

                    So the company must suffer it (even if itā€™s simply just as little suffering as an employee not following a legal policy)? While paying you to do it? Imagine you paying someone to do something explicitly against the contract they signedā€¦ Then taking you to court and winning. This is not how a functional society works.

                    Whatever group you belong to, I believe youā€™d appreciate someone acknowledging the state of the world and how your people have historically been treated

                    Nah, Iā€™m good. Peopleā€™s lives before me doesnā€™t make me who I amā€¦ Iā€™m me in spite of that.


                    I do also want to revisit one other thing you brought up beforeā€¦

                    You must not [ā€¦] music [ā€¦] that shows who you are as a personā€¦

                    So if I prefer music like Spiritbox, Sleep Token, etcā€¦ Do you stand by the logic that I shouldnā€™t be allowed to blare my music while Iā€™m working? Should I have to go into an Albertsonā€™s and listen to WAP blaring on some portable speakers or through their headphones? I mean, thatā€™s who they are right?