So i have (i think) no mucical talent becasue in school i was always bad at music classes and was behind compared to others also i coudent stand all the noises going on. im not sure why but i wanted a keyboard pinao becasue i like the way they sound, once i got one i tried to have some folks teach me but i imeditly got overwhelmed by eveything that goes into playing an instument.
so by chance is there an affordbale instrument for beginner that can be worked on also what can one do once they learn an instument? is it just a skill to show off to others? i pretty much stink at everything but im trying to improve at life or my life more like it. i was thinking of writting songs or doing covers but im not entirly sure how that works.
my hobbys/interests often change often but thats normal (hopefully) and hopefully no one is getting annoyed by me.
This is just my experience as an adult with little music background. I tried guitar and it was not beginner friendly for a few reasons:
Notes appear multiple places on the fretboard, which means chords have tons of forms. This leads into my next point of knowing what to play and where to play it.
For reading music (I know you say just read tabs but tabs have their own issues) there are several notation systems that all get crammed together to make sight reading extra difficult. For any given note, in addition to the pitch and duration from the standard musical notation, there may be instructions for which string to fret, which finger on the right hand to use, and which position to be in (how far down the fretboard your where hand is).
Bar chords. I really hit a wall with these and the awful contortions expected of me to produce these.
Counterpoint or music in two parts. Having trouble remembering where a note is as a beginner or keeping rhythm? How about we add a few more than will be fretted differently depending on what comes before or after and that have a different duration? Now move only some of your fingers so you can let one line ring out while playing together from the other line.
You may say that these aren’t beginner topics, but they’re all covered in the first book I ever learned from that started with how to hold a guitar and notes in the first position.
You had a bad book, then. Those aren’t beginner topics. Don’t learn to read music, it’s a waste of time. I will die on that hill. Use tabs and listen to the song to get the timing.
You don’t need to know many forms of chords at the beginning. Just memorize 4 of them and you can play most songs.
Barre chords are really hard. I don’t think I learned them until like my third year of playing guitar. You don’t need them as a beginner.
I used to teach guitar to beginners. Trying to run before you can walk just gets you frustrated and makes you want to stop trying. You need to learn the basics before you can learn advanced stuff. By basics, I mean, how to strum a single chord. So many books and teachers want to start teaching reading music or chord notation right away, and that’s just dumb imo. Just get a feel for it. Strum open if you have to until you feel comfortable strumming, then add your fretting hand into the mix to make a chord.